As leaders, our decisions matter and impact many more people than when we were just individual contributors.  Depending on the position we hold, our decisions create ripples of impact.  With each decision come dilemmas. Some of these are straightforward, while others can contain ethical implications. What does it mean to lead ethically? Allow me to suggest there is not ethical leadership rather the key lies in leading well through being anchored in solid principles.

Let’s explore a few guiding principles to help you navigate ethical dilemmas effectively.

The Golden Rule and the Platinum Rule

First, let’s revisit a classic: the Golden Rule. It simply advises us to treat others the way we want to be treated. When faced with an ethical dilemma, consider how you would feel if you were in the other person’s shoes. For example, if you are unsure how to address a customer’s complaint, ask yourself: “How would I want to be treated in this situation?” This reflective practice generally leads us to an answer that feels right.

However, the Golden Rule can sometimes fall short. What if how you want to be treated isn’t what they need? Here’s where the Platinum Rule comes into play: treat others how they want to be treated. This principle shifts our focus from our preferences to the needs of those we serve, allowing us to communicate and interact in a way that adds value to them.

When applied together, these two rules offer a robust framework for ethical decision-making.

Head and Heart Thinking

So, how do we put these principles into practice? This brings us to a practical approach known as head and heart thinking. Effective leadership requires balancing logical reasoning with emotional intelligence. First, analyze the dilemma through a logical  lens by considering the facts, implications, and potential outcomes. Then, take a moment to reflect from your emotional center – your heart or gut feeling. By integrating both perspectives, you are more likely to arrive at a well-rounded decision that is ethical and considerate.

Two Questions for Ethical Decision-Making

Now that we’ve covered some guiding principles, let’s focus on two powerful questions that can steer your decision-making process.

1. What is best for all? This question challenges you to think beyond personal gain or the bottom line. Is your decision benefiting the organization while also considering the well-being of your team and stakeholders? Aim for a solution that serves the greater good, reinforcing a culture of integrity and respect.

2. Can I sleep well at night after making this decision? I call this the pillow test. Before finalizing a decision, ask yourself if you can rest easy knowing you acted honorably. Particularly when difficult decisions arise, such as letting an employee go.  Consider whether you can handle the emotional repercussions of your choice. Can you honor that person while also addressing organizational needs?

Navigating ethical dilemmas as a leader isn’t about finding easy answers; it’s about engaging challenges thoughtfully. I hope these principles and questions will assist you in your journey as a leader. Which of these could you put into action over the next week?  If you need help thinking into your leadership contact me for a powerful coaching session.  Keep leading on the high road each day and lead well!

 © 2026 Wheeler Coaching, All Rights Reserved